Shalom Bayit and the Essential Difference

 

והאדם ידע את חוה אשתו
Genesis 4: 1

Harmony between husband and wife is the fundamental basis of a Jewish home. In the Jewish family, men and women have different obligations and fulfill different roles. Because we are conscious that the Creator fashioned us as two different beings. With talents and traits that are necessary to synergize our marriage.

We look alike But we are different. Very different. So different that I’m not sure if you could classify men and women as belonging to the same species. I do not mean only in the physical realm, but more than anything else in the psychological and mental area. Nowadays, thanks to advances in medical and scientific technology, we know much better how the brain and the hormones work. And scientists  have discovered that we are far more different than we supposed when John Gray taught us in 1992 that men came from Mars and women came from Venus. The dissimilarity between men and women is very deep and has a biological origin. This is masterfully explained, among others,  by neurosurgeon Simon Baron-Cohen, a specialist in biological psychology,
in his revolutionary book: “The essential difference”.

Recognizing these differences was never more necessary than in our days.

First, because the level of interaction and communication that is expected between men and women, especially in marriage, is much more intense and active than it was since the beginning of humanity. In the recent past, interaction between spouses was limited and practical. Conversations about the running of the house, material needs and the education of children, etc.  The emotional conversation – the exchange: “how you feel / how I feel”, a dialogue that for the woman is natural and therapeutic – had no place between husband and wife. Women talked about their problems and emotions with other women: mother,  sister and neighbor. Today, however, the expectation of interaction between husband and wife is different. A modern wife intuitively expects her husband to empathize with her emotions, her problems, her frustrations, her doubts and her fears. Most women ignore that for men an emotional dialogue does not come naturally. Men, in general, do not excel in the art of communicating emotions and feelings. For a man, participating in an emotional  conversation requires learning and training. Because when a man faces a problem, he does not feel the need to share or talk about them with other people. Not even with his wife. Man has a different mental mechanism (opposite to that of a woman!) that helps him to process his fears and emotions.
Many men, on the other hand, think that wives talk too much, or that they talk in circles, or that they do not know how to express clearly what they want. They expect their wives to be Alexas or Siris. They do not know that women not only speak to communicate a problem but that they also use communication to vent their problems. Of these fundamental differences between men and women, little is known. Not many people have ever heard that the two brains are “different”.  I know that because I have given several classes on “Female Brain vs. male brain” and I do not usually find many people who know these topics.

Secondly, in our days a large part of modern society does not consider it politically correct to speak of psychological –much less of biological– differences – between men and women. The ultra-feminist view postulates that what distinguishes men from women are strictly social and cultural elements. According to this new liberal ideology “difference” is equal to “inequality”. Therefore, they reason, we should educate the new generation in a neutral way, neither as men nor as women. And then, the differences will disappear.

Ignorance of the innate differences between the genders, the fact that so little is taught about it, and the deliberate denial of these differences, is largely responsible for the present crisis of the institution of marriage.

What to do?

The first time the Tora speaks of love is in reference to Adam and Eve. And in that context, the word the Tora uses to describe love is  “yada'”,  to know”:  “Adam knew Eve, his wife” (Genesis 4: 1). It is very difficult – or impossible – to love another person without knowing her or about her. Without knowing how he or she thinks, how she reasons and especially how he transmits and communicates his emotions. Learning about our spouse and his or her gender, is learning to love our spouse.

 




The Creation of Woman (Gen. 2:21-22)

As we explained last time, man unlike animals, was initially created alone, without a female mate. When man, Adam, sees the animals he realizes two things: 1. That he does not have a mate, like all animals. 2. And that he is a different being, with intelligence. And therefore, the mate he needs (and according to the Sages: “for which the man prays for”) still does not exist. Then the Creator (according to the Sages: at the request of man) fashions a woman.

The creation of the first woman is related in two pesuquim (verses), Bereshit (Genesis) 2: 21-22:

(2:21) Then HaShem caused the man to fall into a deep sleep, and as he slept, He took one of his ribs, and then He closed the wound. (2:22) From the rib that had taken away from man, HaShem designed the woman and brought it to the man. ”

Let us see what the Biblical commentator Radaq (Ribbi David Qimhi, 1160-1235) has to say about this verse.

GENERAL ANESTHESIA

Radaq explains that in Hebrew there are several words to describe different levels of sleep, such as numbness, sleepiness, somnolence, etc. The Hebrew word “tardema”, used in this verse, expresses the deepest level of sleep.”Tardema”, which is correctly used in modern Hebrew to describe anesthesia (hardama), indicates a state of unconsciousness that could be compared to a deep trance or a hypnotic state, where the nervous system does not respond to pain or stimuli. According to Radaq, there are two reasons why HaShem made Adam sleep. 1. Obviously so he does not suffer pain when his rib is extracted from his body. Radaq explains that Adam woke up only once pain disappeared. 2. Adam did not see the “surgical” process of woman’s creation. Seeing this specific process  could have produced in Adam a sense of verticality towards the woman; or could have caused him rejection, by associating the woman with pain or with something that is not pleasant to his eyes.  All this is avoided the “anesthesia”.  And so, as we will see in the next pasuq (2:23), when man wakes up and “discovers” the woman, he becomes fascinated with her.

MAXIMIZING MIRACLES OR MINIMIZING MIRACLES.

Since the times of the Mishna, until today, we find in rabbinical literature two opposite traditions regarding Divine intervention in the Bible, when it is not explicit.  A tradition, formulated mainly by Ribbi Aquiba and his disciples, maximizes miracles and divine intervention. Ribbi Ishmael (contemporary of Ribbi Aqiba) on the other hand, minimizes divine intervention when this is not explicit and absolutely necessary. Example: Ribbí Aquibá argues that the Sukkot that protected the people of Israel in the desert were miraculous clouds that surrounded them from all sides (anana kabod). Ribbi Ishmael, on the other hand, says that they were actually simply huts (sukkot mamash). In general Radaq, Maimonides and biblical commentators who explain the Tora from a linguistic perspective, follow this tradition. Other commentators like Rashi and especially Ramban (Nahmanides) who comment on the Tora from an Agadic (Rashi) or mystical (Ramban) perspective follow the tradition of Ribbi Aqiba.

Now we can better understand what Radaq says about this divine action: HaShem “numbed” man, which he says, is possible by natural methods, and did not extract his rib in a “supernatural” way so that miraculously he would not feel pain, since “The Creator does not intervene miraculously when an act can be realized by Him in a natural way.”

(דע שלא יעשה הא-ל מופת במקום שאין צריך מופת, והפלת התרדימה אינה מופת וחדוש )

YOUR OWN FLESH AND BONE

Finally, let’s look at the deeper meaning of this verse.

First, the rabbis said, the rib is close to the heart. The rib was composed not only by bone but also by the flesh of man. Eva was created more or less as if she were a “clone” of Adam, something created directly out of a previous living creature, therefore almost identical to him (at certain levels). While the animals were created from the same source, and the male animal feels for the female a fundamentally hormonal attraction, man and woman (exclusively!) share or are part, so to speak, of the same body. According to the Tora, man carries a “wound”, invisible but permanent, which is also a loss. Man cannot feel complete without the woman. He lacks something that can only be achieved when he clings to the woman. In other words, in the Tora the attraction of man for woman begins as a need to fill a huge emptiness he has, and to reach his own fullness.

We see, therefore, that before sexuality becomes manifest, man and woman have an “heartfeltly” , ”emotional”, and “deeply psychological” base for attraction, beyond the hormonal factor.




“It is not good for man to be alone” (Gen. 2:18)

לא טוב היות אדם לבדו

“It is not good for man to be alone …” Genesis 2:18

In the second chapter of Bereshit (Genesis) the Tora narrates in more detail the creation of man and woman. The Tora explains that the Creator initially created Adam,  man, alone, without a woman, and only at a later stage He created Eve, the woman.

MAN and WOMAN: WHO IS SUPERIOR?

This order in Creation does not establish or suggest a level of superiority of man. Actually you could argue the opposite. 1. In the Creation account we see a sort of  “evolution” from the least sophisticated to the most sophisticated. First HaShem creates matter: atoms. Then with the atoms He creates the atmosphere and the continents. Only at the end of the Third Day of Creation we see the appearance of the first cells with the creation of plants. On the Fifth DayHaShem brought to existence oviparous animals: insects, birds, fish, reptiles, amphibians. On the Sixth Day HaShem creates mammals, creatures that are superior to the oviparous(warm blood, more complex brain, milk production, etc.). At the end of the Sixth Day HaShem creates man, a mammal but with a higher-Divine element: intelligence. The woman appears at the end. The last Divine creation, which suggests a higher lever of design (ויבן את האשה). The Sages explained that the woman was created with bina yetera, a superior intelligence. 2. Man was created from a “lower” source, the dust of the earth, just like mammals. The woman, and only the woman, was created from a living body, a source “superior” to the dust of the earth.

SPECIAL DELIVERY

There is another very important lesson learned from the order in which the first woman was created. In Bereshit 2:18-20, the Creator shows man the animals. Adam, the first man, is invited to name the animals, thus, recognizing them as a different category of being. The famous biblical commentator Radaq explains that this encounter between Adam and the animals served Adam to recognize himself as a being who, unlike all others, has a superior “divine” element: his spirit, his intelligence. And in addition, although the sexual element still does not appear in this context, Adam also recognized “gender”, masculine and feminine, in the animals. Radaq  says that it was only after (or thanks to) this encounter that Adam realized that he was alone. The Tora Alone in two senses. 1. Man did not find among the animals a “company” (עזר), that is, someone else, of a different kind, but “on a similar level” (כנגדו), in other words, someone on the same mental level as him and with the ability to think and choose. The encounter with the animals helped Adam to understand simultaneously his singularity and his solitude. Perhaps this is the reason why HaShem did not create woman at the same time as man. So that man can come to realize for himself, thanks to his Divine intelligence, that he needs a company. And that this company (or companion) does not yet exist.  The woman was not imposed by God on man. It was the man who asked HaShem to create the woman. The Rabbis of the Midrash expressed this deep idea explaining that after meeting the animals Adam prayed (this was the first prayer!) And asked HaShem a companion at his level. HaShem made man realize that it is not good for him to be alone. Thus, even before a woman existed, Adam already desires that special someone, a woman, next to him.




SHALOM BAYIT: Complain more. Criticize less.

Conflicts and disagreement are inevitable in any healthy long term relationship. Marriage is no exception. Each of us has his or her own personality, character and point of view. Each one of us was raised and educated by different parents. And on top of all that, one of us is male and the other female, which as the Tora hints, were created “opposite” (kenegdo) to each other.

The key for achieving domestic harmony in this area consists in regaining control at how we argue. Are we disagreeing in a way that tensions would probably escalate, or in a way that words would eventually lead to a conflict-resolution?

To succeed, we must become aware of the difference between complaint and criticism.  While complaint is natural and sometimes necessary, criticism is always destructive.
1. Complaint is about specific issues, criticism is an attack on your spouse.  When you complain, you express your frustration with an unsolved problem or uncomfortable situation. When you criticize, you aim, intentionally or unintentionally, at hurting your spouse’s feelings.

COMPLAINT: We don’t go out as much as I ‘d like to, we need to go out more often….
CRITICISM: You are so insensitive, all you want is to go out with your friends…
COMPLAINT: “I have a problem with you not calling when you’re going to be late. I get worried. “
CRITICISM: “Why don’t you call when you’re going to be late? You just don’t care about the rest of us.”

2. When I complain I talk mainly about my feelings. When I criticize, is always about your flaws.
COMPLAINT: “It upsets me when I see the dirty dishes in the kitchen”  
CRITICISM: You left dirty dishes all over the kitchen again….

3. The ideal complaint should have 3 components.
1. A description of my feelings. 2. A description of the actions or things that upsets me. 3. A suggestion of what to do, say, or change.
COMPLAINT: (1) It upsets me when (2) I see your clothing out of their place (3) let me show you how to hang those pants. CRITICISM: You are just incapable of keeping your bedroom clean, are you? I hate to see the type of lazy person you have become.

Unlike complaints, criticism will trigger a defense or a counterattack from your spouse. Which will probably lead to more ad hominem verbal conflicts, quarrels, etc.   It is a loss / loss situation for both, and when pervasive, a self destructive cycle for your marriage.

Identify when you practice criticism, and if you cannot avoid it, turn criticism into complaints.