Shemini Atseret & Simchat Tora
ושמחת בחגך אתה ובנך ובתך ועבדך ואמתך
והגר והיתום והאלמנה אשר בשעריך
דב’ 16:13-15
ושמחת בחגך אתה ובנך ובתך ועבדך ואמתך
והגר והיתום והאלמנה אשר בשעריך
דב’ 16:13-15
In Sukkot, our rabbis said, our livelihood is determined bachag nidonim al hamaim . In other words, assuming we were granted good health to make it to the next year (notice that we ask God to grant us ‘one year at a time’) the question remains: will we be granted the means to maintain a life of dignity?
The key concept that represent our request for a dignified livelihood is the word ‘rain’.
Why?
Because in biblical and Talmudic times, the Jewish farmer would plow the land, saw the seeds, and take care of his field protecting the crops from animals, sickness, strong winds etc. But it is “rain” what will ultimately determine the success of his harvest. Rain is needed for a successful harvest and having then what to eat and rain is essential for our livelihoods and the life of our animals. Drought would kill humans and animals and it was considered one of the worst and most damaging natural tragedies …Rain is the most important requirement for the livelihood (parnasa) of the farmer.
At the end of Sukkot, from the Musaf prayer of Shemini Atzeret this coming Shabbat morning we change the words Morid haTal “You make the dew descend” for “Mashib haRuach uMorid haGeshem“, “You make the wind blow, and the rain descend.” to praise HaShem for the Creation of rain (see also this article) . This text is introduced in the second blessing of the Amida.
It is important to notice that at this specific point we are not actually “asking” God for rain. As we know, during the first three blessing of the Amida we don’t ask God for our needs, rather we praise Him for His power and kindness. When saying Mashib haRuach thus, we are acknowledging (not asking) God that it is by His will that the mechanism of rain is activated, and we are implicitly recognizing that our livelihood depends on Him.
מי ששכח להזכיר “משיב הרוח ומוריד הגשם”, ונזכר לאחר שסיים את ברכת מחיה המתים , אם אמר “מוריד הטל” במקום “משיב הרוח ומוריד הגשם” ,כפי מנהג הספרדים בימות הקיץ , אינו חוזר לראש התפלה כיון שאמר מוריד הטל

See this interesting article about Calabria and the Etrogim https://www.calabriatheotheritaly.com/santa-maria-del-cedro-diamante-citron/
“And, you shall take on the first day [of Sukkot] a fruit of a citric tree (etrog), branches of palm-trees (lulab), a branch of myrtle (hadas) and willows of the brook (‘araba), and you shall rejoice before HaShem, your God, for seven days”. (Lev. 23).
What is special about these plants that we take in Sukkot?The Tora does not explain why we should take specifically these four species during Sukkot. One possible explanation for this omission, in line with the thinking of Maimonides, is that at the time the Tora was given the reason for this commandment was so obvious that it needed no further explanation.The Hakhamim (the Rabbis of the Talmud) offered some interpretations, focusing on what these plants visually represent (four organs of the body -spine, heart, eyes, mouth- all united to serve HaShem); or their perfume and taste ( four individuals of the Jewish people, their study and their virtuous deeds).
PERENNIAL PLANTS My teacher, Rabbi Sa’adia Benzaquén, z “l, used to say that what these four plants represent the “vegetable kingdom” because all of them are perennial plants, i.e., they do not die or lose their leaves in the winter. This is particularly characteristic of the etrog, a fruit, that as the Gemara explains “remains in its tree throughout the whole year (haddar beilano mishana leshana). These four plants also grow in four completely different habitats. The etrog grows in the valleys, the lulab in the desert, the myrtle (hadas) in the mountains, and the ‘araba (willows) on the shores of lakes and rivers.
Their need for water is very different.
THE LIFESPAN OF A PLANT I also noticed a few years ago that these plants get dry at a completely different pace. The plant that dries faster than all other plants is the ‘araba. Willow branches, once cut from their tree, would dry up within a few days. Sometimes, the branches of ‘araba might not survive even the seven days of Sukkot. Then we have the myrtle leaves, hadasim, which would dry up completely in a few weeks. The lulab, the palm branch, dries very slowly, it takes months not weeks to dry up. And finally, we have the etrog. There are several elements that make the etrog a special fruit. But perhaps the most characteristic aspect of the etrog is that it does not decompose, and might last for years. If one leaves, for example, a lemon or any other citric fruit for a few days outdoors, or even in a refrigerator, it will inevitably turn white or green and moldy . The etrog, however, never decays. The etrog will shrink and dries up and it would loss its color, but it would not decompose, and it would preserve its aroma, not for months but for years!
BY DESIGN? Are these characteristics by chance? Although I’m not quite sure how to interpret the meaning or symbolism of these features –and perhaps at the time the Tora was given the reason was absolutely obvious — I do not think that it is just a coincidence that the Tora mentions these specific plants. Why? First, because a fundamental element of the festival of Sukkot is water / rain. During Sukkot we start thanking HaShem for rain (mashib haruah, morid hageshem) , and we also pray and ask HaShem to have a year of generous rainfall, at its due time, knowing that at this time God decides the fate of our crops and produces (בחג נדונים על המים). And these plants seem to represent four different levels of “dependence” on water, and the humidity they contain and preserve. The etrog and the ‘araba seem to be at opposite ends in terms of how long the moisture they keep inside lasts. The main reason why I do not think this interpretation is a coincidence is the order in which these four plants are presented in the Tora. The Tora mentions these four species in a specific order: first, the Tora mentions the fruit that lasts the longer, the etrog. Then, the lulab (palm branch), then the hadasim (myrtle), and at the end the ‘araba (willow): the longer the plant last, the earlier it is mentioned in the pasuq.
MY GARDEN OF EMUNA
This year I planted in my backyard a few tomatoes plants. And I noticed that the tomatoes don’t grow all at the same time: they produce their fruits, one or two at a time, thus, allowing us to have tomatoes for the entire season. I was so amazed and grateful to HASHEM when I noticed that! Then, this year as I was reviewing what I wrote about the reason for these plants I thought of a similar idea: the main reason why the Tora tells us to take these plants and being grateful and “rejoice before HaShem, your God” is because Sukkot happens at the end of the harvest. It should be noted that in ancient times there were no refrigerators or food preservation methods like we have today. And of course it was always necessary for farmers to have food reserves that could last until the next harvest. There are perishable foods that, just like the “‘araba”, won’t last for a long time once they are harvested and they must be eaten while they are fresh. There are also foods that like “hadasim” and “lulab” can last for a few weeks. And there are other foods that can be left to dry like the “etrog”, like figs, dates, and most grains. In His infinite wisdom and goodness the Creator designed perishable foods that need to be eaten fresh, and foods with no expiration date. Perhaps the arba’at haminim, four plants with very different expiration date, represent these characteristics and they give us one additional reason to thank HaShem for his Awesome Creation.
אמר רבי יוחנן: מוליך ומביא – למי שהארבע רוחות שלו, מעלה ומוריד – למי שהשמים והארץ שלו. במערבא מתנו הכי, אמר רבי חמא בר עוקבא אמר רבי יוסי ברבי חנינא: מוליך ומביא – כדי לעצור רוחות רעות, מעלה ומוריד – כדי לעצור טללים רעים. מסכת סוכה ל“ז:
כל זה רומז שהכוונה לבקש מה‘ יתברך על העתיד ולהודות לו על העבר. מנורת המאור שע“ט
In his book, Menorat haMaor, Rabbi Isaac Abohab explains why we do these movements with the Lulab, quoting a text from the Gemara.
Ribbi Yochanan explains that we move the Lulab forward and backward (towards one’s own body) and then up and down to thank HaShem “who is the owner of the four winds,” and to express our gratitude for those winds that brought the rain in due time during the past harvest. Why do we thank God in Sukkot for the good winds? Because on Sukkot the Jewish farmer had already harvested all of his fruits and produce for the year. Being grateful to God is essential, explains Rabbi Abohab, because when we have all the food we need around us, we are inclined to forget God (זמן בעיטה).
Ribbi Yose Bar Ribbi Chanina provides a different explanation: these movements with the Lulab, symbolizing the winds, represent our prayer asking God to protect future harvests, to prevent damaging winds —which bring drought or locusts— and destructive rains that can ruin all the products of the earth.
Which opinion do we follow? To thank God for the past or to ask God for a promising future? Our tradition is to do both during the famous Hallel prayer.
In order to thank and acknowledge God for what he gave us, we move and wave the Lulab as if it were a qorban, an offering to God, saying as we move, “HODU LASHEM KI TOB KI LEOLAM HASDO” Let us give thanks to God when it is good [=when we have abundance], [saying that] ‘His kindness is infinite’, ” .
And to beg HaShem for a promising material future, we move the Lulab while saying ANNA HASHEM HOSHIA NA, “Please, God, save us.” That is, “save us from the destructive winds, from inclement weather that could leave us without food and at risk of dying.
If these prayers about wind, rain, and dew are not very familiar to us, it is because, in our days of superabundance, we have so much food B”H that it is difficult for us to understand the terrible challenges of a year without harvest.
If you look at the four plants we take on Sukkot; you will see that one of the differences between them is the length of time they last until they dry out or decay.
The Etrog lasts the longest; it shrinks but can last for years without decomposing. Then, we have the Lulab, the palm branch, which takes a few months to dry (which is why, when the Matsot were baked at home, it was customary to use the dry branches of the Lulab, adding them to the oven where the Matsot were made). And then there are myrtle or hadasim, which can last a few weeks without decomposing. Of the four species, the most fragile and the one that decomposes the fastest is the ‘araba. Willow leaves last only a few days off their trees, hopefully, a week…
Our rabbis explain that at the end of Sukkot, the Heavenly Court issues the verdict on the rain that will fall this coming year (bachag niddonim ‘al hamayim). This is the main reason why, following a kabbalistic custom, it is customary to stay awake all night on Hoshanah Rabbah studying Tora).
“Rain” is the most critical element for our livelihood. And immediately after the end of Sukkot, the rainy season begins.
It is possible that the ‘araba also reminds us of our vulnerability and dependence on the rain that HaShem sends us. Furthermore, we internalize our fragility by hitting the ‘araba’s branches against the ground and seeing how the ‘araba is defoliating with each blow. Thus, we realize that we entirely depend on HaShem for sustenance and prosperity.
By moving into the Sukka and leaving the safety and security of our solid homes, we are reenacting those glorious days when we were under His “direct protection”, which is ultimately the protection that matters the most.
There are many details and specifications as to how to build the Sukka.
The basic principles are:
WALLS: The walls, usually 3 or 4, must be built first before we place the sekhakh (covering). We could make the walls of any material capable of withstanding an average wind. This is why rabbi Obadia Yosef z”l recommends avoiding fabric for the walls and instructs to use wood or panels instead. See below.
SEKHAKH: We place the ‘sekhakh’ on top of the walls. For the sekhakh we can use all kinds of branches: bamboo branches, leafy branches, palm branches, etc. Special curtains made of reeds or bamboo can also be used for this purpose.
SHADOW vs. RAIN: The sekhakh /covering should be dense enough to provide a shadow that would cover most of the area of the Sukka at noon, but it has to be fragile enough to allow rain to come into the Sukka. An impermeable “hut” is not considered a temporary dwelling and therefore is not a valid Sukka (=pesula).
Most of the Halakhot of building a Sukka are identical for Sephardim and Ashkenazim. See this for a specific rule about the walls, by R. Obadia Yosef z”l.
The rabbis explained that to fulfill the Mitsva of dwelling in the Sukka we should leave our primary residence and settle in the Sukka. They said: “For the seven days of the festival, each person should turn the Sukka into his permanent residence and his house into the temporary one”. Living in the Sukka means that all regular activities we do at home should take place in the Sukka.
Some examples:
MEALS: Except when raining, we should have all our meals in the Sukka. According to Jewish Law, all formal meals -which are defined by the recitation of hamotzi and birkat hamazon– must take place in the sukka. That is why when having a formal meal, with bread, we recite the berakha: ….asher kiddeshanu bemitzvotav vetztivanu leesheb basukka.
MEZONOT: Pastries, cakes, cookies, etc. (mezonot) should also be eaten inside the sukka.
SNACKS: A light snack (a fruit, a salad, coffee) might be consumed outside the sukka. The rabbis praised those who, during the festival of Sukkot, would not eat or drink anything outside the Sukka.
SLEEPING: Sleeping in the sukka is part of the Mitsva of “settling” in the sukka. However, the fulfillment of this Mitsva depends on a few factors: weather conditions (cold temperatures and obviously rain); one’s physical condition (health, sensitivity to cold, age, etc.). In some areas, we should also be aware of safety concerns, like the possible presence of animals (raccoons, foxes, mosquitos, or other insects), etc. this could also be considered a factor to be excused from sleeping in the Sukka.
All regular activities we usually do at home, like studying, reading, napping, relaxing, etc., should also be done in the Sukka.
Fasting in Yom Kippur.
Tefila of Yom Kippur.
Who should fast and who should not?
Children and fasting.
Wearing non-leather shoes.
VIP: What should we learn from the story of Yona?
What is Teshuba and what are the steps that we should follow?
Learning to apologize.
There is nothing wrong with saying, “I was wrong”.
The power of forgiving others.
What should we do every night before we go to sleep?